Batch01 R1
Refinement Table
R1 comparison against v0.1 method-pilot labels. This is not ranking and does not establish decision usefulness.
| Asset | v0.1 overclaim | R1 narrowed claim | Counter-evidence or gap that forced narrowing | Supersession |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BNB | SUPPLY_CONTRACTION_WITH_ECOSYSTEM_UTILITY / COMPLEMENTARY | BURN_LINKED_ECOSYSTEM_UTILITY_REGIME / TEMPORAL_CHANGE | Validator selection and source dependence forced narrowing from utility language to a burn-linked utility regime with control constraints. | REFINED |
| SOL | PERFORMANCE_EXPANSION_WITH_CLIENT_DIVERSIFICATION / COMPLEMENTARY | EXECUTION_SCALE_WITH_PARTIAL_CLIENT_DIVERSITY / POTENTIAL_CONFLICT | Client-diversity evidence remains partly implementation-transition evidence, producing POTENTIAL_CONFLICT rather than a stronger alignment claim. | REFINED |
| TRX | STABLECOIN_SETTLEMENT_RESOURCE_REGIME / CONSISTENT | STABLECOIN_RESOURCE_SETTLEMENT_REGIME / TEMPORAL_CHANGE | Transaction-count evidence supports stablecoin materiality, while resource economy and governance constraints prevent overclaiming full dominance. | REFINED |
| XLM | FOUNDATION_FUNDED_PAYMENT_NETWORK / SEMANTIC_TENSION_BUT_RECONCILABLE | SDF_TREASURY_DEPENDENT_PAYMENT_NETWORK / TEMPORAL_CHANGE | Treasury and SDF mandate evidence remain material, while payments/RWA adoption does not independently displace foundation dependence. | REFINED |